- Home
- What we buy
- Old coins and collections
Selling old coins in Oklahoma City
Blue folders, cigar boxes, mason jars of wheat cents and proof sets ordered every year. We go coin by coin and tell you which ones count.
Book a free appraisal
Coins we buy
- Indian Head and wheat cents
- Buffalo, Liberty and war nickels
- Silver dimes, quarters and halves through 1964
- Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970
- Barber, Mercury and Standing Liberty coins
- Proof and mint sets
- Two-cent and three-cent pieces
How old coins are priced
U.S. silver coins from 1964 and earlier never sell below their silver value. Copper and nickel coins begin at face. From there, date, mint and condition push some coins far above those floors.
We list the better coins separately with grade and price, and group the rest by type with a count and a total.
Collections from all over the state
Oklahoma collections often started small: a grandmother saving every Indian Head cent that came through the store register, a boy filling folders on a paper route in Capitol Hill, a farmer keeping silver change out of circulation in the 1960s when the government stopped minting it.
We see those collections arrive from Bethany, Del City, Mustang and farm towns a long way from the metro. Every one gets the same careful look.
Dates we check closely
Most old coins are common, but these are worth a careful look.
- 1909-S VDB, 1914-D and 1922 plain wheat cents
- 1937-D three-legged and 1913-S buffalo nickels
- 1916-D and 1942/1 Mercury dimes
- 1932-D and 1932-S Washington quarters
- 1938-D buffalo nickels in high grade
- Barber halves from the New Orleans mint
Finding the mint mark
The mint mark is a tiny letter showing where a coin was struck. A wheat cent carries it just below the date on the front. On buffalo nickels it is on the back below FIVE CENTS. On Mercury dimes it is on the back near the base of the fasces. Philadelphia coins usually have none. You do not have to look; we check every coin anyway.
Storage damage
Oklahoma heat and humidity are hard on coins stored in barns, sheds and attics. Copper turns dark or green, and cardboard folders get water stains. Leave everything as it is. We price damaged copper honestly and silver always keeps its metal value.
Proof and mint sets
Sets from 1964 and earlier contain 90 percent silver. Special mint sets from 1965 to 1967 hold a 40 percent half. Most clad sets after 1968 sell near face. Silver proof sets from 1992 on carry silver. Keep sets in their original packaging.
Two-cent and three-cent pieces
The Mint struck two-cent pieces from 1864 to 1873 and three-cent pieces in silver and nickel through 1889. They turn up in older Oklahoma collections passed down from territorial families. Most sell for a few dollars to a few dozen, and the silver three-cent pieces carry a little silver too.
See also: Indian Head penny values
Questions
Are wheat pennies worth anything?
Most are worth a few cents each. A handful of dates, like the 1909-S VDB and 1914-D, are worth much more.
Do you buy partial folders?
Yes. Leave the coins in the folder and we check each one there.
Do you buy foreign coins?
Yes. Silver and gold foreign coins carry metal value, and some carry collector value.
See what your coins and gold bring today
Book a free, private appraisal anywhere in the Oklahoma City metro. We test and weigh every piece where you can watch and write the offer down.